top of page

The World-Making Symbiosis of Science and Religion

We Are All Lichens

lichens.png

This is a book about biology, religion, and climate change. It is framed by the hypothesis: biology and religion need to form symbiotic relationships to combat climate change. The book describes why such alliances are needed and ways that such alliances can be formed. 

​

We Are All Lichens claims that science and religion come from the same source-the wonderment that is generated when the mind apprehends the world. Moreover, biology and religion always have alliances with each other. In the twentieth century, biology and religion agreed to ignore the body as a temporary garment (worn by genes or souls), to view nature as the mechanical sum of its parts, and to separate the spiritual from the physical realms. However, in the current century, new revolutions in biology ("the extended evolutionary synthesis") and in religion ("the new materialism") are becoming capable of forming new alliances that celebrate physical bodies, that view nature as dynamic, interactive, and full of agencies, and that can fight those forces presently destroying the wonders of the natural world. This book is a guide to how this might be accomplished.

​

Central to this book is the new revolution in biology that sees each multicellular organism as a "holobiont," a consortium of different species acting together. Thus, each organism is an individual as a team is an individual.  Human bodies are not self-contained individuals, but are ecosystems, communities of human cells and trillions of symbiotic microbes that develop, metabolize, and survive together. For developmental biologist Scott F. Gilbert, this understanding of life has consequences far beyond the laboratory. It calls for a new account of our responsibilities to one another and to the planet.

We Are All Lichens traces biology’s shift from gene-centered explanations to a science of relationships, processes, and mutual dependence. Embryology shows cells determining each other's fates through reciprocal induction, where organs are constructed from parts made during that construction. Similarly, microbes help form the embryonic brain, the immune system, and the sperm of adult males. The concept of sympoiesis, or "making-with," extends these insights from the developing embryo to the holobiont and ultimately to Gaia, a living world sustained by interspecies cooperation. Moreover, the book also traces current theological discussions seeing traditions of immanent divinity in Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity, and numerous indigenous religions that point to a similar appreciation of embodiment, cooperation, and sympoiesis.

Gilbert argues that neither science nor religion can confront climate change alone. Moreover, their "warfare" is a historical artifact that is not inherent to their structure. Drawing on developmental biology, environmental ethics, and numerous religious traditions, he proposes an symbiotic alliance rather than warfare or synthesis. Science can clarify how life depends on fragile relationships, while religion can help turn knowledge into collective action. Both science and religion begin in wonder, and both will perish if we do not maintain it. 

About The Authors

Scott F. Gilbert is a biologist, historian, and educator who has taught embryology and the history of biology at Swarthmore College for 35 years. He has also pursued research in embryology as a Finland Distinguished Professor at the University of Helsinki, and he is presently a visiting professor at Oulu University in Finland. Dr. Gilbert received his BA in both biology and religion at Wesleyan, and he earned an MA in the history of science and a PhD in biology at The Johns Hopkins University. His research concerns how changes in gene expression or symbiont populations during development can cause evolutionary novelties. He is the author or co-author of several books, including Developmental Biology (presently in its 13th edition); Evolution Evolving (2024); Eco-Evo-Devo (2025); Bioethics and the New Embryology; and Fear Wonder, and Science in the New Age of Reproductive Biotechnology (2017). He has received several academic awards, including a Simon Guggenheim Foundation Award, The Kowalevsky Prize in Evolutionary Developmental Biology, the Biennial Award from the European Society for Evolutionary Developmental Biology, the Service Award from the Pan-American Society for Evolutionary Developmental Biology, and the Viktor Hamburger Prize for education in developmental biology. He is married to Dr. Anne Raunio, an obstetrician-gynecologist, with whom he has three adult children and two granddaughters. Until his move to Portland, Oregon, he was a pianist in one of Swarthmore's premier klezmer bands.

gilbert lichens.png

Donna J. Haraway (Foreword by)

Donna Haraway is Distinguished Professor Emerita in the History of Consciousness Department at the University of California Santa Cruz. She has recently been the recipient of The Erasmus Prize for exceptional contributions to the humanities, social sciences, and the arts. and the Golden Lion for Lifetime Achievement awarded at La Biennale de Venezia.  Writing and teaching in science and technology studies, feminist theory, and multispecies studies, Donna served as thesis adviser for over 60 doctoral students in several disciplinary and interdisciplinary areas. Attending to the intersection of biology with culture and politics, Haraway’s work explores the string figures composed by science fact, science fiction, speculative feminism, speculative fabulation, science and technology studies, and multispecies worlding. Her books include Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene (2016); Manifestly Haraway (2016); When Species Meet (2008); The Companion Species Manifesto (2003); Modest_Witness@Second_Millennium (1997); Simians, Cyborgs, and Women (1991); Primate Visions (1989); and Crystals, Fabrics, and Fields (1976, 2004).

haroway.jpg
Watch a video of the authors and Prof. Bruce Clarke on Mind Matters Dialogue & Book Launch.

Contents

Foreword: Wonder, Gratitude, and the Reciprocal Inductions of Science and Religion  (by Donna Haraway) invites readers to enjoy playful amazement by juxtaposing some of the concepts mentioned in the glossary. It continues with a tapestry interweaving gratitude, wonder, friendship, and the sheer joy of scientific discovery.

 

Preface: Pathways of Becoming is an introduction to the two paths by which the author came to write this book, embryology and liberal Judaism. If someone is going to discuss science and religion, it's good to know what's informing that person's views.

 

Chapter 1, “Wonder and the Possible Alliance of Science and Religion,” shows both science and religion to be descendants of wonder. Wonder generates awe and curiosity. Curiosity begets knowledge, science, and philosophy; while awe begets wisdom, reverence, and religion. 

 

Chapter 2, “The New Biology,” demonstrates that biology and religion always form alliances and that the current alliance, based on competition, genes, and souls, is outdated. A new biology is emerging that can form alliances that will be needed to combat further climate change. 

​

Chapter 3, “We Are All Lichens,” describes a new view of living beings based on the symbiotic nature of all life: All complex organisms are composed of numerous other organisms, such that every organism is a holobiont—both an individual being and a dynamic system of ecosystems. 

​

Chapter 4, “A Sympoietic View of Life,” claims that all organisms are in the process of developing. Even as adults our immune systems keep maturing in ways to help integrate us into the environment. This sympoiesis arises from thermodynamic properties governing metabolism within and between organisms,  eventually forming the metabolism of a planetary holobiont that some have called Gaia.

 

Chapter 5, “The Ethics of Holobiont Awareness,” metabolically enmeshes humans with the rest of the living world, not as discrete organisms but as life cycles that must be completed by our symbionts’ own life cycles. 

​

Chapter 6, “The Way of the Embryo,” shows that this the biology is capable of forming alliances with numerous religions in the mutual rediscovery within their respective traditions of immanent and symbiotic worldviews. Such alliances can promote earthy well-being and may be powerful enough to counter the extractive economics that puts planetary life in peril.

 

Glossary. It's important to distinguish the Eukaryotes from the Eucharist and the Neoplatonic from the Neonicotinoids.

bottom of page